Science times: the human ear rat event be short of regret

Shanghai jiaotong university organization appraisal says "the human ear rat" real mature technology

Science times

In June this year, looked out on the eastern weekly "dispatch says, Shanghai jiaotong university professor LuoShu back scientific research team caoyilin who regeneration" ear cartilage "results exist, and that fake scientific research research funds use has abuses," a fake ears cheated 300 million research funds ".

News, a public outcry. Faced with the huge pressure of Shanghai jiaotong university established the "deal with work leading group", after a busy, in August 26 gave us such a conclusion: the experts identified, LuoShu back renewable "ear" the scientific research results of the cartilage is true; The survey by the state, tissue engineering related topics application and use of funds are standard.

A few days ago, has lost the election in the academician by new andmorecomfortable caoyilin who "interviews that," cheat state 300 million is nonsense ", "scientific research environment is bad," "I'm on the science, science is more important to me. What academicians, not at all important." Now, after the success that he, foreign comment restored calm, "it is not a bad thing, also the scientific research work to withstand time and with social supervision," "I love science, this thing will be more incentive I do it, Chinese will to fight for this tone". "I think a lot of the experiment will soon be able to clinical application, but science things, difficult than imagination will try to do some clinical work, to do the service of the industrialization of tissue engineering enabler." Academician of Chinese academy of engineering ZhangDiSheng for the endorsement, "still is our country caoyilin who tissue engineering research subject leaders of".

So far, the rumor looks quite a bit the collapse of itself, since the taste of qing qing.

However, in this matter, the practice of Shanghai jiaotong university does not seem to perfect:

First of all, the experts JianDingHui not by third party agencies to organized. In China's current social credit a general lack of atmosphere, still make the person a little not trust, there is quite a one-way conversation suspicion. It is said that, to own a zhao4 ben3 shan appraisal result: I this person the most won't talk.

Second, in this not perfect state, in order to withstand test history, people will for the identification of expert committee list have reason to interested. But unfortunately, the only way to the material public information, "by the national related field 4 academicians and four experts academic appraisal committee".

Who are these people? Why not? In? The voice of the questioning of the network is not uncommon, "han core event why not also organize a such appraisal?" , "let a person remember han core is also experts identified, and have many academicians to participate in, the ear identified the Shanghai jiaotong university their rat identification, credible?"

Of course, given in foreign scene to show a be-in-touch meeting ear living "rat", seeing is believing, I would say, no matter the others believe it or not, anyway I am to believe. (macro) of ruan